Skip to main content

Appetizers

Garlic Bread - 6.50
Cheesy Garlic Bread - 7.25
Artichoke Spinach Bread - 10.75
Fried Mozzarella Styx - 11.50
Buffalo Chicken Tenders - 9.00 / 15.00
w/carrots, celery and blue cheese or ranch
Fried Mushrooms - 12.00
Onion Rings - 9.50
Pizza Puff - 5.00

Fresh Cut Fries

*Our fries are best enjoyed in house.

Bag of fries - 4.00 / 6.00
Garlic fries - 7.00 / 10.00
Cheddar fries - 9.00 / 11.00
Loaded fries 10.00 / 13.00
Cheddar or blue cheese, bacon, sour cream, scallions

Salads

Veggie Salad - 9.00 / 13.00
red onion, avocado, blue cheese, kalamata olives, cucumber, tomato, romaine-mix

Chopped Chicken - 11.50 / 16.00
grilled breast, bacon, avocado, blue cheese, tomato, red onion, cucumber, kalamatas, romaine-mix

Antipasto Salad - 17.50
mortadella, capicola, salami, artichoke, pepperoncini, roasted red pepper, red onion, parmesan, romaine-mix

Lefty’s Caesar - 9.00 / 13.00
romaine, sun-dried tomato, parmesan, croutons
w/ grilled chicken breast - add 3.00

House Salad - 6.50 / 10.00
red onion, kalamata olives, cucumber, tomato

choice of dressing:  oil & vinegar, balsamic vinaigrette, ranch, blue cheese, caesar

Italian Beef

Slow-roasted in house, dipped in ‘da jus’, w/ sweet peppers or giardiniera.


Classic Italian Beef - 14.00
Cheesy Beef w/ mozzarella or provolone - 15.25
C.B.G.B. cheesy beef on garlic bread - 16.00
Cheddar Beef - 15.25
The Combo - 15.00
Italian beef, sausage, peppers & grilled onions
Katarina’s Combo - 16.00
Meatball, marinara, sausage & peppers

Dogs & Polish

Steamed & served on a poppy seed bun with mustard, onion, pickle, relish, sport peppers, celery salt, and tomato.
Fresh-cut fries included.


Chicago Hot Dog - 9.00
Chicago Polish Sausage - 10.00
Char-Cheddar Dog - 9.75
Maxwell Street Polish - 10.00
w/ mustard, grilled onions and sport peppers

Sandwiches

Italian Sausage - 11.25
w/peppers & grilled onions
Meatball w/marinara - 13.00
lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, vinegar, spices, mayo, mustard & hot giardiniera upon request
Italian Sub - 12.75
Mortadella, capicola, salami & provolone
Roasted Turkey - 12.75
Turkey breast, Swiss cheese, avocado
Grilled Vegetable - 12.00
red pepper, eggplant, zucchini, pesto & provolone

Char-Burgers

1/2 pound burgers seasoned and charred on the grill.
Served with grilled or raw onion, lettuce, tomato, mustard, ketchup, pickle.
Fresh-cut fries included.


Char-Burger - 14.00
Char-Cheese Burger - 15.50
The Hefty Lefty (double) - 18.00
The Hefty Lefty w/ cheese - 19.50
Char-Chicken Breast - 14.00

Pasta

Al Capone - 16.00
‘rumored’ to be Big Al’s favorite pasta.
linguini, artichoke, bacon, fresh basil, tomato-cream
Lefty’s Carbonara - 16.00
linguini, egg, bacon, parmesan and a touch of cream
Linguini or Penne
w/ marinara - 12.00
w/ pesto - 14.50
w/ meatball - 17.00
w/ sausage - 16.00

Pizzas

Thin & Crispy
Traditionally cut into squares (25 - minutes)
16” cheese - 20.00

Deep Dish
Taste the Legend (35 - minute bake time)
16” cheese - 26.00

Stuffed
The Mother of All Pizzas (1 hour make & bake time)
14” cheese - 34.00

Sides

Marinara sauce - 1.50
Sausage (1 grilled link) - 4.00
Meatballs (3 balls w/ marinara) - 7.50
Giardiniera (hot) - 1.00
A spicy blend of olives, peppers, veggies, garlic & herbs
Sweet peppers - 1.00
Grilled onion - 1.00
Sport peppers - 1.00
Cheese - 1.25
Bacon - 2.00
Sharp Cheddar spread - 2.00
Avocado - 2.00

Specialty Pies

Thin Crust 27.00 | Deep Dish 34.00 | Stuffed 40.00

Pesto Pie - Fresh tomato, ricotta, pesto sauce
Veggie Pie - green pepper, onion, mushroom, olives
Pizza Margherita - fresh tomato, basil, garlic
Spinach Supreme - spinach, mushroom, basil, garlic
Farmer’s Market - mushroom, grilled eggplant, grilled zucchini, garlic

Thin Crust 29.00 | Deep Dish 36.00 | Stuffed 42.00

Meaty Pie - sausage, pepperoni, meatball, Italian beef
South Sider - Italian beef, green pepper, onion, hot giardiniera
Gold Coast - grilled chicken, artichoke, sun-dried tomato, basil, garlic
Monster of the Midway - sausage, pepperoni, hot giardiniera, garlic
The Great Sausage Pie - a full layer of sausage (Deep Dish & Stuffed Only)

Toppings

garlic, black or green olive, kalamata olive, grilled zucchini, grilled eggplant, mushroom, red onion, spinach

Ham, bacon, salami, anchovy, meatball, pepperoni, Italian beef, grilled chicken, italian sausage

Sun-dried, sliced tomato, green pepper, pepperoncini, pesto (sauce), basil

roasted red pepper, giardiniera, provolone, artichoke, ricotta

Know what you want?

Order Online for pick up at either location!

Order Now